THE RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CERAMIC GLAZES


Bekir KARASU, Gamze YÜKSEL and Nilperi UYSAL

Eskisehir Technical University, Faculty of Engineering, Materials Science and Engineering Department, Eskişehir


ABSTRACT

As a result of the technological developments and social expectations, in recent years the studies have intensified on the discovery of new functional glazed ceramic products improving the quality of life with the environmental consciousness. Among all the innovative ceramics those with antibacterial,antimicrobial and antifungal ability, self–cleaning efficiency, photocatalytic activity,mechanical strength, chemical endurance, lightness, anti–slip, and photoluminescence are worth mentioning. The paper aims to give general knowledge of new functional properties and then to summarize the studies recently conducted on the functional ceramic glazes.


Keywords: Ceramic glazes, Innovation, Properties, Developments.


1. INTRODUCTION


Ceramic glazes are homogeneously ground silicate mixtures that are applied onto a ceramic body surface in wet or dry form and then fired to shape a thin layer with many desired properties. Glazessupply several advantages to ceramic surfaces such as cleaning facility, increase in the chemicalresistance, strength, and surface hardness, as well as yielding an aesthetic appearance, all of which depend on the chemical composition of glaze in the first place.


There have been many changes in the ceramic industry over the years. Especially changes in processing led to a significant alteration in glaze compositions, mainly due to the shorter firing cycles, new glaze and decoration application methods, and restrictions on the use of many glaze raw materials.Changes in firing cycles, including the increased use of roller furnaces in the ceramic tile, dinnerware, and sanitaryware industries, have decreased total firing times. There is less time available to burn out organics in the body and glaze, as well as mature the body and glaze at the peak firing temperature.Changes in application like bell waterfall, airless spray, dry application, screen printing, roll printing, disc application, and inkjet printing have dictated thechanges to be made in the composition as well as the suspension of ceramic glazes. Additionally, restrictions on the use of barium, lead, cadmium, zinc, or crystalline silica have led to alterationsin glaze composition [1].


Hereby the recent innovative achievements in ceramic glazes with certain features such as antibacterial, antimicrobial and antifungal ability , self–cleaning andphotocatalytic activity, high mechanical strength and chemical durability, and photoluminescence characteristics are emphasized.


2. HISTORY OF CERAMIC GLAZES


Pottery glazing has been around for almost as long as the human race. It is unknown exactly when people first started glazing their pottery, but most archeologists agree that it was sometime between the 9th and 8th centuries BC.It is believed that the first glazes were developed around 3500 BC in Eastern Mediterranean countries by potters who tried to imitate the precious blue stone lapis lazuli. For this purpose, small beads were sculpted from steatite [Mg3Si4O10(OH)2] and then coated with azurite or malachite powders, natural ores of copper with blue and green colors, respectively. When the coated beads were fired, the coating interacted with steatite to form a thin layer of colored glass. Apart from Egypt, ancient glazes have been found in China, Mesopotamia, and Greece, each of which had developed its styled glazes according to its geography and material properties. Egyptian glazes were largely alkaline–based, as were thoseusedin China and Mesopotamia. Greek and Roman used lead–based or clay glazing. Alkali glazing is one of the oldest forms of ceramic glazing and various materials have been used in glaze contents. In Mesopotamia, ash was mixed with sand to obtain the glaze on the pottery made in that area. In Greek glazes, a mixture of soda and sand was achieved by using extra clay particles. Lead glazing was first used by the Romans from around the 1st century BC. A mixture of lead oxide and sand was placed over the pottery before it was fired [2–3].


In later periods, potters began experimenting with different combinations of crushed and ground rock powder mixed with water to coat the surface of the crocks and pots. Considering that they did not have enough knowledge of chemistry at that time, the process of developing the glaze required a long time and much effort. Over time, potters discovered mixtures that completely covered the surface of the earthenware with a waterproof glassy layer. Then they managed to produce glazes of different colors and textures by using different multiple firing cycles at different temperatures.


In the second millennium BC, lead glazes were developed in Babylon. Lead acted as a flux, which allowed the glaze to form at lower temperatures. In the 8th century BC, the Assyrians in Iran discovered another glaze additive, tin oxide. This additive yields a white opaque glaze that would completely cover the brown or reddish color of clay earthenware. Tin glazes became very popular in the Renaissance period, but their use decreased with the development of lower temperature glazes in the 1700s.


Initially, potteries were glazed to prevent the permeability of porous clay containers used for storing and transporting liquids and food. Later, thanks to the aesthetic appearance glaze provided, it started to be used as a decorative coating for the walls in the form of tiles. One of the oldest and most important examples of the use of glazed tiles in ancient Mesopotamia is the Ishtar gate (Fig. 1), built on the inner walls of Babylon during the reign of King Nebuchadnezzar II (in the 6th century BC). Blue, gold–plated and reddish tiles were used to shape both real and mythological animals [2].

Fig. 1.Lion figure depicted in glazed tile on the Ishtar Gate (Photograph by R. Rincón, taken in the Pergamon Museum, Berlin)[2].


Over time, when potters learned to reach high temperatures, they began to develop truly permanent ceramic glazes. Thanks to the use of chemicals and minerals melting above 1100 °C in the glaze composition, the glazes fired at high temperatures became much stronger and durable. When any art museum is visited today, it is seen that the tile glazes produced in the ancient Egypt period, the Greek vases processed with red and black lined glazes, and the Chinese ceramics made of bright lead glazes and bright celadon retaining their first–day brilliance.


In the late 19th century, German Chemist Hermann Seger developed the Seger Formula, a glaze calculation method. This method, which is easier than the various formulas developed for ceramic glaze calculations, is generally employed in the industry. Seger also developed the Seger pyramid, which controls the temperature, making the firing process more accurately done. Today, studies are mainly being carried out on functional glazes.


3. INDUSTRIALLY PRODUCED GLAZES


Depending on the application being considered, conventional glazes are not fired less than 950 oC but they can be fired up to 1430 oC. Even though oxidizing are used in many cases certain products still need reduction. Glazes are employed in numerous applications, including:

  • Electrical porcelains

  • Refractories

  • TilesWall and floor tiles

  • TablewareCrockery, mugs, ceramic cups, and dinner plates

  • OrnamentsFigurines and giftware

  • SanitarywareBathtubs, toilets, and basins[45]

Here mainly the glazes for tiles, sanitaryware (Fig. 2), and tableware(Fig. 3) will be mentioned.As a result of the technological developments and social expectations, in recent years the studies have intensified on the discovery of new functional glazed ceramic products improving the quality of life with the environmental consciousness. Especially in the tile industry, it is aimed to obtain improved durability and chemical resistance, and in the tableware and sanitaryware fields, it is targeted to develop products with antibacterial and antifungal properties and also to create more hygienic environments with less water consumption thanks to self–cleaning coatings. In addition to these, glazes with photoluminescence features are among the priority studies.

(a) (b)

(c) (d)

Fig. 2.The combination of wall and floor tiles and sanitaryware: (a)From Çanakkale Seramik of Türkiye [6], (b)Vitra Seramik of Türkiye [7],(c)Fabceramishe of Italy[8], and (d) Santa Ceramica of Russia[8].

(a) (b) (c)

(d) (e) (f)

Fig. 3.Some selected samples of tableware: (a) From Güral Porselen of Türkiye [6], (b) Porland Porselen of Türkiye [7], (c) Kütahya Porselen of Türkiye [8], (d)Jingdezhen Porcelain of China, (e)Tai Serax,and(f)Doki Japanese [8].


3.1. The Important Functional Properties for Ceramic Glazes


3.1.1. Antibacterial, Antimicrobial and Antifungal Ability


It has beenrecently demonstrated that highly reactive metal oxide nanoparticles exhibit excellent biocidal action against Gram–positive and Gram–negative bacteria. Thus, the preparation, characterization, surface modification, and functionalization of nano–sized inorganic particles open the possibility of formulation of a new generation of bactericidal materials [10].The antimicrobial activity of silver nanoparticles against yeast, Escherichia coli (E. coli) and Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) was investigated and it was reported that nano–sized silver particles were an effective bactericideand have great promise as antimicrobial agents in various fields such as medical devices and antimicrobial systems [11–12].Marambio–Jones and Hoek published a review paper of the antibacterial effects of silver nanomaterials, including proposed antibacterial mechanisms and possible toxicity to higher organisms. While there is some evidence that silver nanoparticles can directly damage bacteria cell membranes, they appear to exert bactericidal activity predominantly through the release of silver ions followed (individually or in combination) by increased membrane permeability, loss of the proton motive force, inducing deenergization of the cells and efflux of phosphate, leakage of cellular content, and disruption DNA replication [13]. Antibacterial Ag–doped P2O5–SiO2 monoliths were successfully prepared by sol–gel method and the porous structure was formed after heating and it was determined thatthis kind of porous monoliths has a good antibacterial property to restrain E. coli [14].


Stoneware porcelain tiles (extruded or dry pressed) have high resistance to deep abrasion, very low (0.5 %) water absorption, high hardness, and suitable resistance to thermal shock and frost. Unfortunately, such ceramic tiles do not have antimicrobial activity and microorganisms easily grow on their surfaces, particularly in hot and humid environments, which may cause problems to human health. Therefore, the creation of tiles with antimicrobial activity has significant practical and commercial importance. The most common bacteria in the wet domestic environments are S. aureus and E. coli. These are usually found on floors and walls covered with glazed ceramic tiles. At present, public health is a social concern. News about the contamination of pathogenic microorganisms in critical areas such as hospitals, slaughterhouses, restaurants, industrial facilities raise concerns in the community, so antimicrobial and antifungal materials and products are increasingly demanded by a larger market. The emergence of new generation materials that can meet this demand can maintain better environmental hygiene and safety conditions by certain ceramic products with bactericidal and fungicidal properties whose surfaces can prevent or eliminate the growth of pathogenic microorganisms. Thus, to increase the competitiveness in the ceramic industry innovative products with higher quality and high added value started to be developed. However, there is a significant increase in production costs due to the introduction of new stages in the production process. Another problem is that the antibacterial effect of the additives included in the glaze composition by additional heat– or cold–treatment is not long–lasting and the protective layer can be removed from the surfaces by the abrasion forces [15]. Seabra et al. [16] developed the porcelain stoneware tiles having an antimicrobial efficacy above 77 % for S. aureus, and 81 %, for E. coli. They reported that the antimicrobial action results from the combined effect of silver, chromium, and iron ions.


Hydrophobic surfaces are also known to have antimicrobial effects by restricting the adherence of microorganisms. However, ceramic products are produced by high temperature processes resulting in a hydrophilic surface. Özcan et al. modified an industrial ceramic wall tile glaze composition by the inclusion of metallic zinc powder in the glaze suspension applied on the presintered wall tile bodies by spraying. They reported that the micropatterned surface topography of the nanocrystalline ZnO granules imparted an antimicrobial character to the ceramic tile surfaces which werewell correlated with the hydrophobicity. The bacterial proliferation on the tiles with the zinc modified glaze was suppressed up to over 99 % [17].

Fig. 4 inhibits the antibacterial sanitaryware product of Creavit Co. of Türkiye.

Fig. 4. Sanitaryware product with antibacterial properties [18].


3.1.2. Self–Cleaning and Photocatalytic Activity


Self–cleaning surfaces possess an important place in the plastic, metal, textile, and ceramic industries, and many studies have been carried out to improve this feature. The concept of self–cleaning glass was first introduced by Watanabe et al. [19] in 1992 on titanium–coated ceramic tile. Midtdal and Jelle [20] aimed to give a comprehensive stateoftheart review of the selfcleaning glazing products available on the market today and investigate methods for measuring the selfcleaning effect.Selfcleaning products from several manufacturers that utilize two different selfcleaning technologies of either photocatalytic hydrophilic or hydrophobic capability are presented. The photocatalytic hydrophilic products in question are selfcleaning glazing products readytouse when purchased, whilst the presented hydrophobic products are coatings that must be applied to existing glazing products in order to yield a waterrepellent and selfcleaning surface. Fig. 5 presents the illustration of how selfcleaning glass works [20].

Fig. 5.Illustration of how selfcleaning glass works, in three steps, from left to right: (1) activation of the coating by UV radiation and natural dirtying, (2) decomposition of the organic dirt, and (3) rainwater washes away the loosened and degraded dirt (Pilkington Group Limited) [20].


In the self–cleaning process of a hydrophilic surface, water droplets form a thin layer on the surface. This smooth spreading plays an important role in removing dirt on the surface. It also allows the surface to dry faster and become more transparent. In other words, it prevents misting/fogging of surfaces. On hydrophobic surfaces, water droplets roll on the surface, while carrying dirt and showing self–cleaning properties [21–22]. Nanostructures can be employed to create hydrophobic surfaces, forming air gaps that prevent the contact of the surface with liquid. In this area, SiO2 [23] and CuO [24] additives are used to obtain a lotus–like effect.


Self–cleaning efficiency increases in outdoor environments where the material may be exposed to rain and water flow. In this case, the surfaces are required to have a super hydrophilic property. Thus, with the reduced water contact angle, it forms a thin water film on the surface and makes it possible to wash the impurities that do not decompose. For this reason, self–cleaning ceramic tile will perform better on super hydrophilic surfaces with a high decontamination rate. To obtain such surfaces, titanium dioxide (TiO2)is used.It decomposes organic pollutants by exhibiting photocatalytic properties and provides a hydrophilic surface to promote water distribution on the surface to complete the self–cleaning process [25].Fujishima et al. [26] reported that the best usage of self–cleaning TiO2 surfaces should be on exterior building materials because they are exposed to abundant sun exposure and natural precipitation. Although TiO2, which is employed in surface coatings under normal conditions, creates hydrophilic surfaces, hydrophobic surfaces can also be formed when TiO2 is used in nanoscale. Fig. 6 shows a ceramic washbasin with a self–cleaning glaze.

Fig. 6.Ceramic washbasin with a self–cleaning glaze by Foshan OVS Sanitaryware Ceramic Co. Ltd. of China [27].


Although increasing industrialization provides economic benefits, it also brings environmental problems with it. Today, news about diseases that arise due to environmental problems in industrial areas draw attention. One of the most sensitive issues of the European Union countries is the protection of the environment and hence human health. Therefore, the production and development of environmentally friendly products are one of the main topics that have been studied in recent years. Industrial pollution, in particular, affects both the pollution of the environment and the life of the buildings. Besides, environmental pollution causes the growth of bacteria and viruses that adversely affect human health. For this reason, it is essential to develop self–cleaning, environmentally friendly photocatalytic systems that both reduce air pollution and degrade bacteria, viruses, and toxic organic substances. Traditional ceramics do not have antibacterial or photocatalytic effects against microorganisms and organic pollutants. The presence and reproduction of these pests on ceramics are undesirable for human and environmental health [28–30].


Photocatalytic systems cause active oxygen formation when exposed to UV. Active oxygen has properties such as oxidation of organic substances on the coating surface, bacteria–killing, organic stains removal, and removal of unwanted odors in the air [31]. The cheapest and most powerful photocatalyst employed in photocatalytic reactions is TiO2 in the anatase form. Since TiO2 is a semiconductor, non–reactive, and inactive substance, it remains in the environment and ensures the cleaning process.Fig. 7 exhibits self–cleaning mechanism with a photocatalytic effect.

Fig. 7. Self–cleaning mechanism with a photocatalytic effect. Stage 1–When the surface of the tile is exposed to sunlight, it produces a thin layer of active oxygen, which reduces the static cling of dirt particles present in the atmosphere.Stage 2–The active oxygen breaks down the dirt, thusreducing its adhesion capacity/strength.Stage 3–The exceptional hydrophilic properties of tile facilitate an even distribution of water between the surface of the ceramic material and the layer of dirt; the drag of the water (H&C Tiles of Grespania Ceramica)[32].


The photocatalytic process is described by six reactions. The process begins with irradiating the semiconductors with UV light. When the semiconductor absorbs energy equal to or superior than the bandgap, an electron is transferred from the valence band to the conduction band. In TiO2→ h++ e–reaction, h+, which has great reducing power, reacts with water (moisture) to generate hydroxyl (OH), which also presents high oxidizing power. On the other hand, e– accomplishes the reduction of oxygen molecule to produce superoxide anion (O2–), which is very effective on pollutants’ degradation.The O2– reacts with H+, dissociation from water, and forms HO2. From these radicals, pollutants gases, mainly NOx, are degraded. The final product, HNO3, can be washed by rainwater[33]. Titania is one of the most widely used benchmark standard photocatalysts in the field of environmental applications. However, the large bandgap of titania and the massive recombination of photogenerated charge carriers limit its overall photocatalytic efficiency. The former can overcome by modifying the electronic band structure of titania including various strategies like coupling with a narrow bandgap semiconductor, metal ion/nonmetal ion doping, co–doping with two or more foreign ions, surface sensitization by organic dyes or metal complexes, and noble metal deposition. The latter can be corrected by changing the surface properties of titania by fluorination or sulfation or by the addition of suitable electron acceptors besides molecular oxygen in the reaction medium [34].


TiO2 has three different crystal structures which are anatase, brookite and rutile. TiO2in the anatase form is the most efficient of photocatalysts for many applications. The bandgap energy of anatase TiO2is 3.2 eV and it can be only activated by UV light. Although UV light is present in the solar spectrum it is only a very limited part. For practical applications, the photocatalytic activity of TiO2needs further improvement. Doping TiO2with transition metals or noble metals is an effective way to improve photocatalytic activity.In the literature, there are several studies thatare related to the doping effect of silver. Researches which are performed on the effect of silver dopant are focused on the change of optical and electronical properties of TiO2. Moreover, since silver itself is known as a strong anti–bacterial agent it is used as a dopant for improving anti–bacterial properties of TiO2. Doping silver can give rise to the separation of electron–hole pairs and can accelerate the formations of oxidative species. In addition to this, silver can reduce particle size which is needed for increasing surface area of TiO2 [35].


3.1.3. Mechanical Strength and ChemicalEndurance


Thanks to the glazes applied to ceramic surfaces, surface dirt and deposits can be easily cleaned. However, these surfaces that are resistant to daily environments can wear out over time and lose their surface properties when being negatively affected by high or low pH valued environment. At this stage, varying the glaze content or applying a coating on the glaze surface can be used to increase and improve the surface resistance [5]. Floor tile glazes are constantly exposed to abrasive effects, especially in public areas. Depending on factors such as traffic density and the type of abrasives in such places, high abrasion resistance is expected from floor tiles. The abrasion resistance of the glaze is one of the main factors that determines the life of ceramic coatings due to the continuous abrasive effects. This resistance is improved by increasing glaze hardness. One of the ways to increase the hardness of glaze is the use of suitable glass–ceramic systems in which the harder crystal phase or phases are developed from the glassy matrix [36].


The degree of contamination and cleaning of the glaze surfaces depend on the surface micro– and macro–roughness respective to the chemical composition of the phases. Alkaline detergent solutions typically used to clean daily living surfaces cause pitting on surfaces containing wollastonite and pseudo wollastonite. The glaze recipes prepared with diopside crystals with high abrasion properties provide abrasion resistance against acids and bases as well as surface gloss. Moreover, the sol–gel technique is a very versatile method to deposit ceramic coatings in combination with a dipcoating process. The resulting coatings are of high purity and structural homogeneity. They are mesoporous and very thin as well as with defined crystalline structure and generally presenting good adhesion to the substrate [37–42].


In general, glazes show good chemical resistance in aqueous solutions. However, depending on the composition of the glaze, solution, temperature, and other conditions, ion changes, dissolutions, and absorption reactions can occur on the glaze surface. Corrosion taking place in the glaze results in a decrease in brightness, discoloration, and leads to pitting or decomposition on the surface. The chemical resistance of glazes is often interpreted by the durability of the amorphous phase, because the crystal phases in the glaze structure are assumed to have higher durability. Generally speaking, the reaction kinetics vary depending on the glaze formulation, chemical and mineral composition, and grain size of the raw material during the firing process.


It is difficult to achieve a desired and controlled surface appearance when using raw glazes in ceramics fired at lower peak temperatures or shorter firing cycles typically applied for glazed tiles. The use of frit formulations has been recently increasing. However, raw glazes are a low–cost alternative to fast–fired and fully condensed ceramics, such as frost–resistant floors and swimming pool tiles, due to their high peak firing temperatures.


3.1.4. Photoluminescence Effect


Photoluminescence is described as the event that any material can emit light after absorbing photons. The light emission eventis called photoluminescence since it is initiated by photoexcitation. When materials are stimulated with light, their electrons reach high energy levels, and the stimulated electrons release photons to return to lower energy and more stable energy levels. At this stage when photons are released, glare/glow occurs. Photoluminescence can be divided into two classes: fluorescence and phosphorescence. In both cases,materials absorb light and emit photons with less energy and shine in dark. However, when the excitation source disappears in fluorescent materials, the light emission ends immediately. In phosphorescent ones, the light emissionoccurring after the excitation source removed can take minutes or hours.This group is generally preferred for applications where phosphorescence pigments continue to emit light when the stimulation ends. Long–lasting phosphors have been developed in the SrAl2O4: Eu2+, Dy3+ systems, which emit light in blue, green, bluish–green, and yellowish–green colors, have been developed.Photoluminescent glazes are obtained by adding photoluminescent pigments to the glaze compositions. They are applied to the ceramics, absorb visible light, and gain a glowing ability in the dark, consequently adding value to the end products. Such an ability is not only evaluated for decoration in houses and other buildings but also is used in floor coverings to prevent confusion and provides guidance in emergencies. Photoluminescent ceramics can emit light at certain wavelengths, which can restrict certain molds and diseases.Thanks to this feature, it is preferred in kitchen and sanitaryware products. They are resistant to corrosion, friction, burning, and aging[43].Figs. 8–9 present luminous ceramic mosaics and proenvironment photoluminescent ceramic tiles respectively.

(a) (b)

Fig. 8. Luminous ceramic mosaics of Foshan Miclear Ceramics Technology Co. Ltd. of China, The appearance (a) in daylight (b) in the dark [44].

Fig. 9. Proenvironment photoluminescent ceramic tiles of Pacific Industry Co. of China, The appearance (a) in daylight (b) in the dark [45].


4. The Recent StudiesConducted on Ceramic Glazes


There have been many studies on the development of glazes with new features. Some of those made between the years 2000 and 2020 are summarized below.


Eppler conducted researches on the chemical abrasion resistance of glazes against various chemical solutions and concluded that the results depend on firing conditions as well as glaze composition [46]. Yalçın and Sevinç utilized bauxite waste in ceramic glazes [47].Karasu et al. developed and characterized zinc crystal glazes used for Amakusa–like soft porcelains [48]. Çakı and Karasu evaluated albite wastes in stoneware glazes [49].


Karasu et al. made compositional modifications to floor tile glazes opacified with zircon [50]. In another work, Karasu et al. studied the effect of albite wastes on the glaze properties and microstructure of soft porcelain zinc crystal glazes [51]. Karasu and Turan reported the effect of cobalt, copper, manganese, and titanium oxide to zinc–containing soft porcelain glazes [52–53]. Karasu et al. applied the phosphorescent glazes on bricks and roof tiles [54]. Qing et al. investigated the effect of infrared radiant powder addition on glaze development and antibacterial and antifungal activity [55].


Karasu and Tosuner microstructurally studied limonite containing satin and opaque wall tile glazes [56]. Torres and Alarcon made researches on the effect of additives on the crystallization of cordierite–based glass–ceramics as glazes for floor tiles [57].


Karasu et al. utilized the concentrator wastes of Etibor Kırka Borax Company of Türkiye in the recipe of an opaque frit used for wall tile glazes as an acid boric replacement [58], evaluated these wastes in soft porcelain opaque glazes as an alternative fluxing agent [59], investigated the effects of the red mud–based pigment addition on the physical and microstructural properties of porcelain tiles [60] and used Tunçbilek thermal power plant's fly ash in stoneware glazes as a coloring agent [61]. In the study of Vane–Tempest et al., the chemical resistance of fast–fired raw glazes in solutions containing cleaning agents, acids, or bases has been examined [62].


Karasu et al. reported the effects of red mud–based pigments on wall and floor tile glazes [63] and developed the abrasion–resistant diopside–based glazes suitable for floor tiles by compositional modifications [64]. Hupa et al. searched for the chemical resistance and cleanability of glazed surfaces [65]. Torres and Alarcón published the paper on the pyroxene–based glass–ceramicglazes for floor tiles [66], and on the effect of MgO/CaO ratio on the microstructure of cordierite–based glass–ceramic glazes for floor tiles [67]. Torres et al. investigated the effects of some additives on the development of spinel–based glass–ceramic glazes for floor–tiles [68].


Rong has a Ph.D. study on the synthesis, characterization, and biological applications of inorganic nanomaterials and determined that silver nanoparticles exhibit more antimicrobial activity than silver nitrate in the same concentration. This finding suggests that low–toxicity silver nanoparticles may be antimicrobial agents [69]. In the works of Yekta et al. floor tile glass–ceramic glaze for the improvement of glaze surface properties has been examined [70]. Torres et al. worked on the mechanism of crystallization of fast fired mullite–based glass–ceramic glazes for floor–tiles [71], and also published the paper on the effect of boron oxide on the microstructure of mullite–based glass–ceramic glazes for floor–tiles in the CaO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2 system [72].


Agné conducted a study on the silver ion–containing glaze and concluded that sanit